Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of highly derived, obligate nutritional symbioses between insects and fungi

From: Patterns of functional enzyme activity in fungus farming ambrosia beetles

 

Coleoptera

Diptera

Hymenoptera

Isoptera

Ambrosia beetles

Bark beetles1

Ship-timber beetles

Gall midges

Wood wasps

Fungus-growing ants

Fungus-growing termites

Insect family

Curculionidae

Curculionidae

Lymexylidae

Cecidomyiidae

Xiphydriidae, Orussidae, Anaxyelidae, Siricidae

Formicidae

Termitidae

Mutualistic fungi

Ascomycota (Ambrosiella, Raffaelea, Fusarium)

Ascomycota (Ophiostoma, Ceratocystiopsis, Grosmannia) Basidiomycota (Entomocorticium)

Ascomycota (Endomyces)

Ascomycota (Lasioptera, Ramichloridium)

Basidiomycota (Cerrena, Stereum, Amylostereum); Ascomycota (Daldinia decipiens, Entonaema cinnabarina)

Basidiomycota (Leucocoprinus, Leucoagaricus and the family Pterulaceae)

Basidiomycota (Termitomyces)

Age of symbiosis(Mya)

21–60

?

?

?

?

45–65

24–34

Agriculture

       

Mode of nesting

Xylem tunnels & chambers

Phloem tunnels & chambers

Xylem tunnels

Plant galls

Xylem tunnels

Subterranean nests (occ. mounds)

Subterranean nests and mounds

Substrate for fungi

Surrounding wood

Surrounding phloem (and wood)

Surrounding wood

Surrounding plant tissue

Surrounding wood

Collected plant material (twigs, caterpillar feces, leaf litter, flowers, fruits, fresh leaves)

Collected plant material (dry leaf litter, twigs, wood)

Mode of agriculture2

Advanced

Primitive (possibly advanced in Dendroctonus)

Primitive

?

Primitive

Advanced

Advanced

Enzymatic profile

       

Fungus garden (incl. microbial community)

xylem degrading saprotrophism and bionecrotrophism5

bionecrotrophism of phloem

?

?

xylem degrading saprotrophism

Saprotrophism (saprobic and biotrophic in leaf-cutting ants)

Saprotrophism (plant cell-wall degrading)

Fungus acquired enzymes3

Possible5

?

?

?

Present

Present

Present

Mode of feeding 4

       

Adults

Mycetophagy

Phloeomycetophagy

No food

Plant sap

No food

Mycetophagy, (plant material)

Mycetophagy, (plant material)

Larvae

Mycetophagy (Xylomycetophagy6)

Phloeomycetophagy

Xylomycetophagy

Mycetophagy

Xylomycetophagy

Mycetophagy

Mycetophagy

  1. 1 Here we only refer to bark beetles in nutritional symbioses with fungi and omit species only feeding on phloem.
  2. 2 Primitive fungiculture is defined by only dispersal and seeding of fungi; advanced fungiculture additionally involves the active care of fungal crops (cf.[9]).
  3. 3 Evidence for fungus acquired enzymes that are active in the insect gut or fecal exudates[13, 62].
  4. 4 Distinctions originating from the scolytine beetle literature e.g.[20]: Mycetophagy = eating fungal mycelium, fruiting bodies or specific fungal structures, Phloeomycethophagy = eating phloem and fungal biomass, Xylomycetophagy = eating xylem and fungal biomass.
  5. 5 Reference: this study.
  6. 6 Only in larvae of the genus Xyleborinus and probably Xylosandrus[21, 32].