Skip to main content

Table 2 Number of species (N), average discrimination (AUC or Area Under the Curve), and classification values (Sensitivity, Specificity, CCR or Correct Classification Rate, Und or Under Prediction Rate and Ove or Over Prediction Rate) for all species, and separately for Threatened species (T), non-threatened non-ubiquitous species (NtNu), and ubiquitous species (U) of the models based on expert criteria and on species records

From: Using fuzzy logic to compare species distribution models developed on the basis of expert knowledge and sampling records

According to experts

 

Species

N

AUC

Sensitivity

Specificity

CCR

Und

Ove

T

12

0.98 (0.961–0.995)

0.97 (0.857–0.999)

0.94 (0.845–0.969)

0.94 (0.845–0.969)

0.00028 (0–0.00168)

0.90 (0.657–0.986)

NtNu

22

0.82 (0.475–0.999)

0.87 (0.361–0.999)

0.68 (0.211–0.998)

0.69 (0.24–0.998)

0.0044 (0–0.0266)

0.93 (0.636–0.992)

U

14

0.5 (0.5–0.5)

1 (0.999–0.999)

0 (0–0)

0.083 (0.0472–0.152)

0.92 (0.848–0.953)

All species

48

0.767 (0.475–0.999)

0.93 (0.361–0.999)

0.55 (0–0.998)

0.58 (0.0472–0.998)

0.0021 (0–0.0266)

0.92 (0.636–0.992)

According to species records

 

Range

N

AUC

Sensitivity

Specificity

CCR

Und

Ove

T

12

0.974 (0.90–0.997)

0.95 (0.75–0.999)

0.93 (0.870–0.970)

0.93 (0.871–0.970)

0.00020 (0–0.000609)

0.92 (0.738–0.988)

NtNu

22

0.92 (0.732–0.999)

0.86 (0.406–0.999)

0.82 (0.215–0.999)

0.82 (0.231–0.999)

0.0061(0–0.0284)

0.91 (0.667–0.992)

U

14

0.73 (0.659–0.873)

0.66 (0.534–0.854)

0.64 (0–0.758)

0.65 (0.170–0.762)

0.11 (0.00945–0.999)

0.85 (0.740–0.907)

All species

48

0.88 (0.659–0.999)

0.82 (0.406–0.999)

0.79 (0–0.999)

0.79 (0.170–0.999)

0.036 (0–0.999)

0.90 (0.667–0.992)